Posted by Hodders 2008-06-22 06:25:27 ....
     I liked it, great emotions conveyed here. + Report this comment |  |
Posted by sTiCkFiGuRe 2008-06-22 07:45:57 good
     Very well constructed poem. Not all poems need to rhyme...did i spell that right. Anyway, There are a couple things I will critique about this piece. Firstly, the phrase on the 3rd line makes no sense..(I drank from your water)..say what? Secondly, Although (I) believe you're speaking of a country, I can't be sure...what or who is Erin? But over all, good poem.
My opinion...
Your third line should be...
I have tasted your fruit and bathed in your water...sounds good to me... but its your poem. + Report this comment |  |
Posted by garyowen 2008-06-22 15:18:49 ....
Ashokan is a town in NY State that was flooded for a dam. Erin is old name for Ireland, the fruit and water mentioned are the gift from the land -Askokan- + Report this comment |  |
Posted by Amatayo 2008-06-22 19:23:13 Hmm
     I really didn't understand the poem until your comment but really when the poem is well constructed you would not need to say what the poem is talking about because the poem already said it. + Report this comment |  |
Posted by Pilgrim 2008-07-04 18:10:10 ....
     Didn't quiet keep my attention. Seems to me the word, think, was used in a repetetive way. Repetition usually throws me for a loop. + Report this comment |  |
Posted by harmattan 2008-08-10 06:40:28 Farewell
     What is it about Erin that makes her call back more of her departed sons than any other country.
I'm with the Lee Marvin character in Paint Your Waggon
"Home is made for coming from
And dreams of going to
Which with any luck
Will never come true".
The last line should have started with "But".
Apart from that, interesting work and a pleasure to read.
Kind regards
harmattan + Report this comment |  |